What are equity markets discounting? it is not risk

 

The Iran conflict is not over, yet the markets are optimistic. Perhaps it is because we don’t know what to call this oil crisis. Is it a war? A dispute? A current pause? The SPX was up over 10% for the month. The high beta names were up over 15%. For the sector extremes, the communication services sector was up over 18%, while the energy sector was down 3.45%. Surprisingly, emerging markets were also up over 11% for the month and strongly higher over the last 12 months at 32%.  Even bonds were slightly higher for the aggregate index.Yet the market is facing a significant commodity shock, with the DJCI up 31% so far this year.

Is there anything to worry about? Central banks? Growth? Inflation? The markets are either looking through any negativity or do not believe it even exists. This is a path that should concern any investor. 

Periods of Stagflation - there have always been with us

Despite strong performance in equity markets, there is still considerable talk of stagflation. The stagflation story is not just a 70's problem. It can happen in other countries and almost any time. It is more likely that we have a supply shock that can affect both prices and growth. The longer the oil crisis in the Middle East lasts, the greater the likelihood that we will see stagflation. Stagflation has generally been short-lived because the underlying cause changes. An energy crisis is averted through a new supply or a solution to the initial problem. 

Right now, we are not close to the 2% inflation target, and the cost of higher energy is just starting to bite. The likelihood of a stagflationary period in the second half of the year is increasing.

Risk aversion index worth a look

 

There is a growing number of risk measurement indices, although the definitions of these risk or uncertainty indices are not always clear. We can start with the VIX index, which is not really an uncertainty or risk index but a proxy for option volatility and is often called a fear index. There is a set of policies and economic indices, derived from news scraping, associated with countries and topic areas.  

Another entrant to this field is the risk aversion index.

The general estimation philosophy is as follows:  

​

(1) The risk aversion coefficient is utility-based, reflecting the time-varying relative risk aversion coefficient of the representative agent in a generalized habit-like model with preference shocks.                                                          
(2) Given the no-arbitrage framework, asset prices, risk premiums, and physical/ risk-neutral variances are exact functions of the state variables, including risk aversion, in the dynamic (exponential) affine model.

(3) Financial variables are observable. Thus, the market-wide risk aversion should be spanned by a judiciously-chosen instrument set of asset prices and risk variables. We use the Generalized Method of Moments to estimate their optimal linear combination given asset moment restrictions that are consistent with the dynamic no-arbitrage asset pricing model. The instrument set includes a detrended earnings yield, corporate return spread (Baa-Aaa), term spread (10yr-3mth), equity return realized variance, corporate bond return realized variance, and equity risk-neutral variance. 

I find this risk aversion index fits the story expected when there is higher uncertainty, and could be worth following as another indicator of changing behavior in financial markets.