Showing posts with label risk management. Show all posts
Showing posts with label risk management. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

FVI shows some heightened risks

The FVI shows that we are at heightened vulnerability in the economy, even with stronger growth. The FVI is perhaps a better indicator of the future than current GDP estimates, which are, at best, concurrent and, at worst, lagging. The hope is that GDP is gaining momentum. Unfortunately, this useful tool is only calculated through the first quarter of 2026. 

What is useful is that FVI can be broken into four subindices: valuation, funding, financial leverage, and household and business borrowing. Household and business borrowing looks to be under control. It is the government borrowing that is problematic. Funding risks have moved up quickly but have not reached elevated levels. Nevertheless, valuation and leverage levels are at extremes. My guess, without replicating the work, is that the subindex values have all moved higher given the current increases in interest rates. 

Monday, October 5, 2026

Financial Vulnerability Index FVI heading in wrong direction


Fed economists have developed a new Financial Vulnerability Index (FVI) that aims to provide a better long-term view of structural risks in the economy. The Fed’s Financial Conditions Index offers a short-term view of the financial environment. Still, the Fed’s new Financial Vulnerability Index (FVI) aims to capture structural issues and provide a longer-term perspective on sensitivity to stress. The index comprises 39 components across four sub-indexes: valuation pressure, household and business borrowing, financial leverage, and funding risk. 

This looks like a nice addition to the existing NFCI index.

One hopes this will become part of the FRED database and be updated on a regular cycle.

1. Valuation Pressures
  • Focus: Overvalued asset markets.
  • Function: Monitors whether asset prices (such as equities, real estate, and corporate bonds) are unsustainably high relative to economic fundamentals. High pressures mean the market is prone to sudden, damaging price corrections.
2. Household and Business Borrowing
  • Focus: Nonfinancial sector leverage.
  • Function: Tracks total debt levels building up within families and corporations. When businesses and households are over-extended, even minor drops in income can trigger widespread defaults.
3. Financial Leverage
  • Focus: Financial sector risk-taking.
  • Function: Measures the degree of debt and leverage being used within the financial sector itself (banks, broker-dealers, and hedge funds). High leverage means small asset losses can quickly wipe out a firm’s capital.
4. Funding Risk
  • Focus: Systemic liquidity and structural maturity mismatches.
  • Function: Evaluates the presence of volatile, short-term wholesale funding that could evaporate rapidly in a crisis (e.g., severe deposit runs or sudden freezes in overnight lending markets).

Tuesday, August 18, 2026

Big losses - big mistakes in finance from leverage

 


There are some common themes when it comes to large losses in finance - leverage kills. We cannot say that it is always the case, but a review of the biggest trading losses seems linked to excess leverage. Too much risk with a surprise event, and you have a recipe for losses. This will happen with funds and financials, and if we dig into corporate losses, we will find a link to leverage. What is surprising is that we haven’t had more large losses, given the spike in rates after the long period of low rates. 

We need risk management to protect ourselves from our leveraged behavior. 




Monday, August 17, 2026

Peter Lynch on stop-loss



Selling your winners and holding your losers is like cutting the flowers and watering the weeds - Peter Lynch 


Peter Lynch was not a quant or a trend-follower, so it may seem odd that he is talking about trend-following fundamentals, yet the premise of Lynch's argument is clear even for fundamental investors. Hold your good companies and get rid of the bad ones. This does not always have to be based on price. It may just be related to the underlying firm characteristics. However, the thought is always the same. Rid yourself quickly of those weeds and tend to your flowers.

Thursday, July 23, 2026

Periods of financial stress - the long history

 


A paper that has not received much attention focuses on measures of systemic risk in "Systemic Risk Measures: From the Panics of 1907 to the Banking Stress of 2023". Much of the data from this paper is available from V-lab. The work suggests that there have been more stress periods recently, but their duration has been shorter. There has not been a stress period since the banking crisis of 2023. More importantly, the work examines what happens cross-sectionally to firms when they enter periods of stress and identifies specific institutions that face risk. 

The stress measures focus on US financial firms' stock return comovements and can predict market outcomes like realized volatility and returns, balance sheet outcomes, and bank failures. The stress periods focus on the contribution and exposure versions of CoVaR, marginal expected shortfall MES, and SRISK. 

Stress periods are identified through a two-step process based on narrative analysis, with start and end periods associated with the GZ credit spreads for more recent periods. 

The key finding is that market-based indicators offer distinct information that complements traditional balance sheet metrics for risk assessment. 



SRISK around the globe - Look at China

 


There is concern about the risk in the current markets given the high valuations. In a perfect world, investors would like early warnings of market stress as an indicator that it is time to rebalance portfolios. Identifying different stress indicators will allow investors to triangulate on the true market environment. One that I have been recently focused on is SRISK from the website V-Lab. 

SRISK measures the capital shortfall of a firm conditional on a severe market decline, and is a function of its size, leverage, and risk. The current numbers show that the world SRISK is falling. There has been a significant decline in developed markets, but emerging markets are moving to high levels specifically because of the large increase in China risk. As a large economy, China's risk is passing through to the rest of the world.

The concern is spillover risk from China to the rest of the world.





Monday, July 6, 2026

Going broke and not taking profits



Good investors focus on risk. Risk is the downside. Bernard Baruch said it well when he said nobody ever went broke taking a profit. - Sam Zell


This is a classic rule in trading, yet it has little meaning. Anytime you have a positive profit, you can take it, yet you are likely leaving money on the table. Simply put, do you take profits on what could be noise or price variation due to current volatility? 

Perhaps better to take profits against valuation. This requires some valuation statement that may be a mistake, but it is a better requirement for profit-taking. 

Nobody ever went broke selling at or above fair value. 

Tuesday, May 26, 2026

Follow the equity risk premium

 


There should be an equity risk premium over bonds. Equity is riskier than bonds, yet the current market does not suggest this. The bond market has disconnected from equities. One can always say that bondholders are pessimists relative to equity optimists, yet there is more going on than just behavior. 

Bonds are pricing stagflation, while equities, through cap-weighted indices, are pricing an AI productivity revolution. Perhaps both can be right, but that does not bode well for holding equity in traditional companies. 


Saturday, March 14, 2026

Risk management is in the preparation


Don’t panic. Yes, it is time to start to panic. But what is panic? It is a forced action in response to the threat of uncertainty. An investor does not know what to do. There is no precise plan of action because the environment and market behavior are unclear and highly dynamic. Market actions, as reflected in prices, are unclear, and players' actions within the market cannot be determined. 

The only way to deal with a panic is through careful planning. But how can you plan for what may not have been anticipated? The only solution is to run scenarios or thought experiments on possible reasons for panic and then work through possible responses. This is not easy, and there is no reason you will get the drivers of panic right, but by conducting these exercises, you will identify common themes for addressing the unknown. 

Monday, March 9, 2026

Uncertainty about signals and price impact



Every model will have signal noise or uncertainty, and every model will have imprecise impact uncertainty from trading. This is a certainty because any training set will have to be imperfect. Hence, we should expect performance problems due to parameter uncertainty. Modelers should take this into account in their work. 

First, the model’s Sharpe ratio will be lower than expected from what is generated from the training set. There will be estimation error and model misspecification. Second, the model will affect transaction costs, with the impact being greater for smaller and less liquid stocks. Notably, weak signals will have less impact on trading costs, while strong signals will have a greater impact on trading costs. See “Trading with Uncertainty about signals and price impact”.

How do you solve these problems? One way to solve the problem is to define a reference model and then assess the costs associated with variations from it. The uncertainty can be managed to lock in a reasonable Sharpe around the reference level. The math in this paper is not easy, but the key is to be aware of the problem and to place bounds on what is possible.  

Wednesday, March 4, 2026

Good News - Bad News - overreaction to the bad news


There is good news and bad news that comes to the markets through new information that impacts expectations. News will have a differential impact, and investors should always be ready for it. Good news will drive prices higher, and of course, bad news will have the opposite effect, yet news will have a differential impact. Good news will usually be met with underreaction, while bad news, at the extreme, will be met with overreaction. To put it simply, the bad news forces investors to sell, and there has to be a buyer on the other side of the trade. To find the buyer, the markets will have to overreact to provide the buyer with a premium for considering the higher risk posed by the bad news. In the case of good news, there is no forced selling that requires new buyers. There will be a reaction, and there may be some extreme buying, but the buying excess is driven by a supply shortage, not by a need for a premium to induce buyers. 

Saturday, February 14, 2026

Risk appetite is always worth following - Currently, normal



We have been following the Wilmot Risk Appetite Index for decades, when it was first called the Credit Suisse RAI, as developed by Jonathan Wilmot, who is now in private practice. It will be provided to investors through HedgeIndex LLC in the coming weeks, along with their broad set of alternative indexes. The basic construction is provided below. 

The current reading indicates that risk appetite is within the normal range, though it is rising. There may be individual assets with extreme values, but the RAI does not indicate a general market extreme.

 

Friday, February 13, 2026

What are the big risks of 2026?


Each year, the World Economic Forum provides a global risk perception survey. This is one of the most comprehensive risk surveys, and it provides useful context on what business leaders are thinking about potential disruptions to the global economy. The benefit of this survey is that it provides overall rankings for each year and measures change from the prior year.

By far, the current global risk landscape identifies geoeconomic confrontation as the top risk, followed by state-based conflict. Now, for anyone reading the news, this seems very logical, but it is sobering to see it in print. It has moved up from the eighth spot last year to number one. Along with confrontation, economic downturns, inflation, and bubbles pose key risks. These risks are important in both the short and long term, although climate change is still considered a long-term risk.

What does this mean? First, it is hard to believe that risky assets will continue on the current path with these views. Second, as noted in a recent post, Bonds are not always a safe asset; holding bonds may not provide the desired safety during an armed conflict or war.





 

Monday, January 19, 2026

Combining volatility (fear indexes) - a strong indicator

 


We know that many investors use the VIX index as a fear gauge or just a measure of market risk. We also know that the same investors use the MOVE index to measure volatility and fear in the bond market. Some researchers decided to look at the divergence between these two indices as perhaps a stronger signal; see "Divergence of Fear Gauges and Stock Market Returns". The authors find that the divergence of fear indexes (regressing MOVE on VIX and using the residuals and the MOVE/VIX ratio) is a negative predictor of future equity market returns. This predictor does well for both in-sample and out-of-sample tests. 

Looking at the difference between MOVE and VIX indexes is a simple measure that can be followed by almost any investor. Simplcity may make this indicator obsolete if "everyone" is using it, but in the near term, we think this is a good, simple signal tool that I have been using for some time in different forms.

Saturday, January 3, 2026

 


Risk means more things can happen than will happen  - Elroy Dimson 


I view risk as the dispersion of countable events. Uncertainty is the events that are not countable, yet the Dimson definition hits home as a key description. It is the range of what is possible, both good and bad. For volatility, the dispersion from the mean says more things can happen than will. For uncertainty, more possibilities are riskier than fewer. Although we focus on the bad, risk can also be a positive.

Monday, December 29, 2025

Risk is not uncertainty




“For uncertain matters there are no calculable probabilities whatsoever. We simply do not know.” -Keynes 


As we move into the new year, we hear projections about what will happen in 2026. It is a fool's errand. These projections are often not grounded in risk assessments, which are countable and measurable. They are framed in narratives. More importantly, they are focused on uncertainty, which means there are no calculable probabilities. Some have defined this as radical uncertainty, but we do not need the adjective. We just do not know the likelihoods, and in most cases, the analysts of these forecasts will not provide probabilities. They are just stories and should be viewed as such. 

Sunday, December 7, 2025

FT geopoltical mood index - another way of viewing sentiment

 


The FT has developed a new geopolitical sentiment model by using an LLM that identifies positive and negative stories, which are then weighted by relevance. This model is correlated to some other geopolitical models, but with a weekly frequency, it may provide a better estimate. The intuition is reasonable and consistent with actual events in 2025. For quant, it would be nice to see that this adds value in telling us the direction of market risk premia.
 

Thursday, November 20, 2025

Where are the expected shocks for next year?


A Fed survey shows that the most significant potential shocks or risks in the market are not bubble risk and overvaluation but policy uncertainty and geopolitical risks. These macro risks are more complex to hedge for the long-only crowd and harder to handicap, as they are based on events that most investors will have a hard time researching. The expansion of the war in Ukraine or tensions with China cannot be assessed in a balance sheet or an income statement. 

Watch the macro risks that are hard to handicap. 

Watch the market liquidity - hidden risk

 


A key statistic to watch is the market liquidity in equities and Treasuries. If there is a market shock that increases risk, there will be a move out of equity and into bonds. If there is a rate shock affecting the safe asset, there will be a shift out of long-dated Treasuries into cash. In both cases, a key cost will be the bid-ask spread and the cost of exiting the market. 

Equity liquidity is still below average, though higher than during the spring period associated with tariff shocks. Treasury liquidity has increased substantially since the second quarter, but liquidity in the 2-year Treasury remains low. 

Liquidity is not a concern until you need it, so risk management should consider the exit costs before a crisis.

Tuesday, October 7, 2025

The big events - they will always be coming


 

Graham Capital provides a simple infographic on the major market crises for the last 30 years. They happen frequently. While crises are not an annual event, investors should expect unique crisis events more frequently than expected if economic policy is working effectively. Interestingly, most of these crises can be linked to bad policy choices. There will be a reckoning when monetary and fiscal mistakes are made.