Sunday, October 30, 2022

Just read the newspaper - Signal on the count of the word "recession"


Read the newspaper every day. It is a good habit, yet with an efficient market, the news you are reading is old and should not be of much value. However, a recent paper suggests that if you just count the number of times the word "recession" is used in the WSJ and FT, you will have a pretty good recession indicator. In fact, a media recession indicator (MRI) is as effective or better than many of the well-known financial indicators. See "What is the value of financial news?". 

Is this useful? The authors show that if you are willing to follow their raw score, it can give a good indicator of recession six months in advance. Value can be generated by selling risky equity assets when the count reaches a threshold. Now, I don't know if I will do the count for 10 years waiting for that one trade, but it does provide a clear indication that following the themes and memes in newspapers can be helpful.   

The most provocative part of this paper is that a MRI may be a better indicator of recession than some of the market based measured. At the very least, tracking the MRI will enhance an investor's ability to track a recession. This is just an enhancement of using news headlines, when converted into an index, can provide unique information. 

Mentions of the word recession clearly increase before a recession. There is greater focus on the business cycle. The MRI clear matches other measures of recession such as term premium, default spreads and the GDPnow nowcasts. When investment decisions are conditioned on MRI, there is significant value-added relative to a buy and hold strategy. Watch news stories. 







Investors always face regret - It needs to be controlled

 


There is not enough discussion on the impact of regret with investment decision-making. Regret is focused of many parts of life, and it haunts many through their lives. A regret survey program suggests that there are regrets that linger for decades for some people. So why wouldn't regret play a meaningful impact on our trading decisions.? It does but we often don't discuss it. We often don't us the phrase, "I regret that trade...". Of course, many behavioral biases are tied to regret. 

Regret aversion suggests that investors are not willing to decide because of the fear that the decision may turn out to be wrong and then you will have to face the consequences of your actions. Regret can be a powerful and discomforting state. 

Regret aversion is the action we take to not have face uncertainty. Uncertainty causes us to delay decisions because we fear our actions will then lead to regret. It is not just the result being wrong but that we are responsible for that wrong result. 

The prospect theory of Kahneman and Tversky is a method of measuring regret given there is more pain from downside than gain from upside. The disposition effect of prematurely selling asset that have gains is a result of regret. Classic utility theory does not match the human behavior that suffers from regret. 

A good simple book on regret frames the broad problem that everyone faces, see The Power of Regret: How looking backwards makes us move forward by Daniel Pink. This is not an investment book and will not give you secrets for making more money; however, it will provide some food for thought on the regret problem that is different from the cold testing of behavior biases. It does try and offer some methods for dealing with the pain from regret.


Regret will focus on counterfactuals and is tied to emotions. There is the "if only" and "at least" counterfactuals. The "at least" focuses on the fact that some situations could have been worse. The "if only" counterfactual haunts us with the damaging, if only I did more. Thinking about "if only" situations is personal and what we most want to avoid. 

Regret creates emotions. If these emotions are ignored, we are delusional. If regret feelings are fed, it can turn to despair. If the feelings are focused on why the regret occurred, it can turn into something positive. Regret is something natural and must be controlled and channeled to reach better future decisions.

Saturday, October 29, 2022

Monetary policy as triage


 

Think of the central bank as an emergency room doctor with the economy as its patient. This is the analogy used by MIT professor Kristin Forbes at the recent State Street Bank conference. The patient comes in as a different code which determine the severity of the emergency and the requirements for the doctor.

Code Red - The patient is near death and critical condition. Emergency work needs to be done immediately and with urgency. The perfect recent example is the gilt crisis in the UK. There was a major bond crisis which needed attention through purchase of bonds regardless of current policies.

Code Orange - The patient is sick and needs immediate care, but it is not a life-threatening crisis. Providing liquidity through repo and reverse repo could be thought of as a reasonable response to a problem that could turn into a crisis if action is not taken. 

Code Yellow - The patient is coming to the emergency room with ill health, but it does not mean there is a crisis or severe sickness. It is an issue that must be attended to, yet it may not require extra focused attention. In this case, the economy could away from full employment or inflation is away from target and the Fed needs to take action to reach policy goals. The issues can be dealt with through the regular central bank meeting schedule. The patient must be given medicine and treatment. There is a potential problem, but it is not severe if addressed.

Code Blue - There is no serious problem but there needs to be a discussion and action to maintain long-term health. The Fed balance sheet needs to be adjusted back to the core through QT. This is not a crisis, but if no action is taken the health of the patient will turn negative. 

Of course, this analogy assumes the central bank / doctor is not the cause of the problem. The central bank has not taken an oath to do no harm. If the central bank does not stay attentive, you can see how a code blue or yellow can move to orange or red. The central banker always must stay attentive to ensure he does not fail the patient.

Doves, hawks, dragons, and pigeons - the state of the Fed

 


We usually make the distinction between Fed officials as either doves or hawks. Hawks focus on inflation while dove are easy on inflation and more focused on employment. Our scorecard of Fed presidents and board of governors place them on a dove/hawk spectrum. However, we may have to broaden or enliven the spectrum. 

Perhaps chairman Powell is not a hawk but a dragon who will go scorched earth on inflation. Rates will rise until inflation is broken and we get it back to the 2% target. There will be no prisoners, no pause. The Fed will accept a recession albeit the forecast is for a small one. 

The Jackson Hole comments and September FOMC press conference represent a dragon not a hawk. With the November meeting, we will learn if he is still a dragon or just hawkish. The latest GDP number suggests that the dragon will remain.


There are also central bank pigeons, birds that peck at issues but do not seem to have any direction. We have the BOC and the Aussie central banks pulled away from higher expected hikes. They are not doves, but worried pigeons. We have the ECB suggesting a possible pivot and not following through on a strong QT plan. They raise rates but almost apologize for having to do it. They are not doves. They are not really hawks. They are worried birds who are afraid of making a mistake. 

Overall, a simple dove/hawk spectrum is not helpful in these complex times.