Tuesday, March 9, 2021

What do you get versus what you may want with EM ETF's

If you buy the most liquid equity emerging markets ETF (EEM), you will be purchasing an Asian-centric portfolio with over 1/3 of your exposure in China and over 60% in just three countries, China, Taiwan, and South Korea, and over 80 percent in Asia.  

On the other hand, if you buy the leading emerging market bond ETF (EMB), you are holding a very different regional exposure. An investor will hold 4.5 times as much LATAM and less than 1/5 of the exposure in Asia. There is more diversification of country exposure in the bond ETF, but the country mix is very different from the equity ETF. 

Both ETFs reflect the exposures in their respective equity and benchmarks. There is no hiding what the ETF will represent. There is complete transparency with the exposures, yet retail flows may not be aware of the regional bets taken. Holding a mix of equity and bond EM ETF or benchmark exposures give very different geographical exposure. The bond benchmark will grow with the amount of debt being issued. More leverage will increase EM bond exposure. More equity growth with increase the country equity exposures. 



The issue of what you are buying with these ETF's is not limited to regions. In the case of EMB, there is a mix between investment grade and high yield, respectively 60% and 40%. Most of what is being purchased is sovereign bonds and not corporates. For equity investors, buying EEM is not an EM commodity play given the diversification of sectors. 

Given the mix of assets, any quick purchases may generate surprises for investors who don't think through the portfolio exposures gained.  

Monday, March 8, 2021

Positioning does not suggest primary dealers are "Bond Vigilantes"

 

Who are the bond vigilantes in the Treasury market today? I want names. Well, I would settle for a sector or a group of players. Treasury primary dealers are one group that could be likely suspects as evidenced by their inventory positions. If levered dealers thought rates should fall, they would lighten their holdings. We could see net positioning fall. Dealer positions are noisy data but with the right analysis, you can extract some important information on the tilt in market rates. However, the evidence on their views is weak. 

There was a big increase in long positioning with the March liquidity collapse, yet net positions do not tell a story of dealers selling off inventory in anticipation of rate increases. Long bond positioning has been stable. 10-year Treasuries have shown a decline to negative in February, but positions in the sector have been relatively low for some time. The shorter maturities have also been relatively stable since summer. A question exists as to whether dealer inventories are too low relative to the supply being generated but that is a separate issue.  



Factor premium returns differ across business cycle - Investors need macro business sense



Equity factor risk premia will do better, on average, than the market premia, but that does not mean that these factor premia returns don't change through time. These factors will be highly sensitive to changes in the business cycle. Now the sample sizes are relatively small since we have had a limited number of business cycles, but if we allocate returns across four regimes and across regions, we will have some idea of how these factor premia returns change conditional on the economic regime.

The business cycle can be divided into four parts, recessions, slowdown (below trend growth), growth above trend, and recovery (the period after a recession). A close look shows which factors should offer higher returns during different cycle periods. 

The intuition in the behavior makes sense. Hold low beta in a recession and drop during growth periods. Drop market risk during a recession and add during a recovery. Of course, the key problem is determining what is the current phase of the business cycle and predicting turning points. If stocks markets are forward-looking mechanisms, the impact of different business cycle regimes becomes all the more apparent. There is value if you can anticipate business cycle regimes before the market. Playing the factor premia investment game requires a sense of business cycle positioning. However, as history has shown, this is not an easy problem.

Know the current regime.
Anticipate changes in the business cycle.
Understand what has been discounted in the market. 
Exploit the difference between business cycle forecast and level of market discounting. 


Recent research by Research Affiliates suggests that there are a number of added complexities with looking at factor premia across the business cycle. There is the change in fundamentals, a change in price ratios or valuations, and the impact of rebalancing since there is sorting or repricing of the factor premium. 


 

Saturday, March 6, 2021

Equity factor premia through time - Variable but persistent

 


Equity factor premiums have underperformed relative to the expectations of many investors, but the longer history suggests that holding a portfolio constructed around an equity risk factor would have outperformed the market risk premium. If you are an active trader, you care about recent performance. If you are a longer-term allocator, you care about playing the odds from large samples. 

This, of course, does not mean that holding equity risk premia are risk-less either in the short or long-run. It does mean that care should be taken in the selection across time and the business cycle. There is time risk - some factors will underperform for an entire decade. There is also business cycle risk. Equity factor premia will change with economic growth. 

We can draw some general long-term conclusions across equity factor premia. 

In 6 of 9 decades, all equity factor premiums beat the market portfolio.

Only once was market risk in the top two spots in a decade and never in the top spot.

Momentum has done better than the market risk premium in every decade.

In only one decade was momentum not in the top two spots.

Low volatility has generally been a lower return premium except for the recent period. 

The differential between the best and worse equity factor premium was never more than 10%.

Regardless of current factor premium dislocations, it is worth focusing on differences in core risk premia.