Friday, June 1, 2018

Monthly performance does not follow an expected return script - Improvisation in value, growth, and small cap indices

One way to measure market uncertainty is to run a simple thought experiment. A well-behaved market should match performance with events in a well-defined manner. An uncertain complex market environment would behave in an ill-defined manner. Close your eyes and assume you have knowledge of the news highlights for the month of May. For example:

  • Political turmoil in Italy and the EU
  • Off-again/on-again North Korea talks 
  • Good economic data albeit with lower momentum
  • EM problems in Turkey and Argentina 
  • Trade war discussions

What would you expect?

The results for May were quite different from what many would expect for some asset classes. A flight to quality and a Treasury rally seems consistent with the news. Similarly, a decline in developed equity and emerging markets also seem consistent. However, the strong showing with small cap, value, and growth are out of character in the current environment.

Small cap, growth, and value indices all had gains of over 5 percent for the month even with higher volatility in the last week. Core domestic equities did better than global, emerging, and large cap stocks. These numbers are inconsistent with a flight to quality or risk-off behavior by some international investors. Unfortunately, the key drivers for May are political headline risks which are difficult to handicap. There is little evidence that can be used to provide likelihood for further momentum or mean reversion.


Thursday, May 31, 2018

The systematic trend trading fallout from Italy - Political shock impacts returns


Political shocks have market consequences. An examination of current financial markets against simple trend and momentum indicators suggests that the trading around the Italian political news was not pretty for systematic trend-followers. In the US bond markets, prices have rallied through 20, 40, and 80-day moving averages in just a few trading dates. This same pattern can be seen in Europe. Short-term rate changes like the Fed Funds and Eurodollars futures one year out have shown an even more exaggerated pattern on a relative basis.



What has the Italian government uncertainty done in the last ten trading days:
  • It reversed the major themes in financial markets.
  • It was a shock and not anticipated by markets 
  • It created a global contagion regardless of what some may have said by many pundits.
  • It is not a crisis, but has generated an adjustment in expectations. 
  • The price impact has shows an over-reaction with some reversal as expected with events generating high uncertainty which have not been resolved but pushed forward.
  • It is expected to have a longer-lasting effect as measured by one-year Eurodollar and Fed funds. 
This is a classic non-countable, non-measurable event that will harm trend-following managers which focus on measurable, countable, and repeatable events that evolve over time. Systematic funds were caught wrong-footed as measured by the reaction in '40 Act fund performance which provides daily return information. A representative sample shows similar return pattern for the month of May. Gains from trends earlier in the month were reversed in the last two weeks as financial markets rallied on fear and a flight to quality.

What can investors do? The only viable option is style and time diversification. Shorter-term traders may have been able to exploit the reversal. Non-Trend style investors were less impacted by the shock, albeit there was enough spread dislocation to hurt all but the most prescient traders. 



Tuesday, May 29, 2018

What keeps me up at night - "The glaringly evident that we have decided not to see"

"The hardest thing to explain is the glaringly evident which everybody has decided not to see." Ayn Rand 



The table is a short list of issues that should cause concern for any investor. A growing problem is that many are not focusing on the broader return implications for these risks, the chance for contagion and second order effects.  Perhaps we have not had the right catalysts to create focus. Perhaps we are being too dramatic in the current risk-on environment, or maybe these are just not really big problems. 

Nevertheless, these issues are keeping me up at night and they have not been given enough weight when measuring the potential return to risk for even diversified portfolios.

Monday, May 28, 2018

You may not want to be bound to an algorithm - so use a dashboard as a decision support tool

The benefits from using algorithms are well documented, yet they are still not used for many decision-making situations. The reasons for this lack of use are varied. It could be self-interest. It could be algorithms anxiety. It could be a lack of confidence in the modeling process. If there is a high level of uncertainty concerning the most effective model, there may be fear of being wrong. 

What we do know is that the more structure to the problem, the less noise or error there will be with any decision. Dan Kahneman discusses the problem when he wanted to use algorithms with a group he was advising on soldier selection in the Israeli army. There was significant pushback from his client, so he came up with a compromise solution of using the set of factors involved with the decisions as a scorecard. The scoreboard of key success factors would be filled out with the final decision in the hands of the client given the factor information. The scorecard or checklist always led to decision improvement that was better than no checklist and almost as good as the algorithm.

There may be an effective middle ground approach for any decision-making that would work well for those who do not want to turnover decision-making to an algorithm - a decision information dashboard.

Dashboards are being used more frequently in businesses across a wide number of fields. They are generally focused on providing up-to-date information on constantly changing data. This tool is perfect for investment management and can be more informative than a checklist. Bloomberg terminals have been tricked out as dashboards for years, but with new visual displays of information and flexible business analytics tools, dashboards have taken on greater usefulness and timeliness. The dashboards can incorporate the process of an algorithm in an easy to read format.

A dashboard can focused on specific decision-making through using graphics and scoring of key variables employed in a specific decision. For example, a simple scorecard on fixed income could include state of the overall economy, shape of the yield curve, momentum, carry, expected inflation, and Fed policy. These scorecard factors could be set to flash red or green based on the score. The set of signals can be aggregated to a fixed income buy/sell score. 

The decision can still be placed in the hands of the trader, but the likelihood of a noisy decision is reduced since the decision-maker would have to act against the factors that he believes are important for the decision. Mistakes will be made and the dashboard may signal false positives, but the chance of misdirected actions will be reduced. The dashboard could be set actually signal what multiple algorithms would do. The decision-making problem could then focus on disagreement with these algorithm assessments. A feedback loop can be established for any set of decisions, so that the decision-maker's action can be matched with the dashboard score.

Dashboards can force discipline on investment decision-makers. There is a problem if the dashboard advice is not taken or proves to be inaccurate, but it is a good way to impose algorithm-lite structure on decision-making.