Monday, May 30, 2011

Reasons for higher commodity prices

After a poor month of index return performance, the story for being long commodities should be revisited. There are five stories for why commodities will go higher and one major story for a continued downturn in commodity prices.

The rationale for higher commodity prices -

The long-term cycle -

The long-term up cycle for commodities is based on emerging market growth. This growth is still dominate for commodities. The improvement in wealth has changed the diet for many in these countries. The increase in overall GDP growth has increased the demand for building materials, energy, and foodstuffs. The growth in the EM middle class is significant and surpassing the size in the US. The marginal buyer of commodities will not be the US or other developed countries but will be the BRIC countries, and non-OECD countries.

The lack of long-term investment in mining agriculture and drilling has meant that supply will not be able to meet the current upsurge in demand. While this is not a peak-oil type story, the cost of finding, extracting and growing commodities has increased significantly. There is a lag between price increases and investment in commodities. There is also a lag between the investment and actual production. Higher volatility has also reduced the amount of investment in many commodities. Higher uncertainty will reduce long-term investments. Finally, in the case of agriculture there is less land available for production and the cost of inputs such as water have increased significantly

Even if there is a slowdown in growth in such countries like China, its overall size will still have an impact on commodities that did not exist even three years ago.

The natural business cycle -

The business cycle has turned up and commodity prices will increase with the surge in global growth. History has found that commodity prices have peaked late in the business cycle and the length of the current recovery is still relatively early. By this simple measure, there should be a room for significant increases in commodity prices.

The monetary policy cycle -

The aggressive easing by the Fed has lead to significant declines in real interest rates. The negative real interest rates have been good for the commodity markets. Analysis finds that negative real rates leads to more purchase of commodities because the cost of holding commodities has decreased. Easing monetary policy also leads to increases in inflationary expectations which will also increase the demand for commodities. A successful monetary easing will also increase overall economic growth which should have a positive increase on commodity demand.

The bubble story -

Tied to the monetary story is the idea that at low cash rates, there is increased demand for risky assets. This demand has gotten out of control and has pushed commodity prices to levels associated with a bubble. The markets have been pushed to higher levels given this unusual demand for risky assets and the lack of any return on cash assets.

The bad weather story -

Many commodity markets have been faced with bad weather which has affected the ability of commodity producers create or generate supply. The global drought in many agriculture markets have been matched by floods in other geographical areas. The poor weather has pushed prices to high levels given the low inventory to usage for many commodities.

The rationale for lower prices -

The false growth story -

The potential for a sustained decline in commodity prices is based on the false growth or recovery story. Reduced fiscal stimulus, ineffective monetary policy, and poor balance sheets in the developed world makes for a slow growth environment and a high likelihood for a double dip recession. There is a strong group of economist who are negative about prospects for the economy. However, the general consensus is that growth will actually increase in the second half of the year, but there do seem to be strong headwinds against a robust growth story.

The long-term trend in the dollar is down

The dollar has had a nice bump higher, but the long-term trend for the dollar is still lower. This is a trend that has been occurring since the mid-1980's. There are four reasosn for the strong negative trend and there is little that the US can do to stop this process.

The ascent of emerging markets -

The growth and wealth creation engine has moved to emerging markets from the developed world. A key catalyst was China joining the WTO in 2001. China joined the global economy. India joined the global economy and a host of other nation have improved their competitiveness relative to the rest of the world. the result has been higher growth and wealth creation that is almost unprecedented on its speed and size. The non-OECD countries now represent half of global GDP. Emerging markets are running trade surpluses relative to the developed world and productivity is improving for their export goods. Factor equalization is occurring.

The US can improve its trade and increase its exports with a dollar decline and productivity increases, but the trend for GDP to be generated in non-developed countries will not change radically. Trade between countries away from the US is also increasing which means that dollars may be less likely needed.

The end of the "Washington Consensus" -

Policy solutions and economic liberalism will not be coming from developed countries. The EM are looking to find alternative policy approaches. The idea that the World Bank or the IMF will call the shots on international financial policy has ended. This is simply a matter of voting blocks. The EM will have more votes on the IMF. The developed world and the US will have less, so coalitions without the US may be able to be formed. There already is the view that EM will not be dictated policy in a crisis like in the 90's. This means it will be harder for the US to impose its policies around the world.

The end of dollar "exceptionalism" -

Central banks around the world have moved to diversify away from the dollar. There has been a general move to hold more Euros, but this has not been an easy choice given the sovereign crisis. It has meant that gold is being purchased by many central banks. Certainly, there is less reason to sell gold from central bank vaults.

The global imbalance -

The US will continue to be a major net debtor.The EM will be major net creditors. The imbalance is being reduced but will still require structural changes which are not dollar positive. The dollar will have to decline to allow for trade improvement. US savings rates will have to increase which means that growth will have to be slower relative to other countries. In this world, the US will be less likely to take currency leadership role.


The dollar will not always go down, but the economic power structure means lower US dominance - a multi-polar finance environment.

QE2 ending may lead to more uncertainty

QE2 is expected to end in a month, but there is still high uncertainty on the potential market direction for the summer given the macroeconomic environment.

There has been a close link between quantitative easing and stock prices. Since the announcement of QE2 last August, the S&P 500 has gained almost 30 percent. A similar gainwas associated with QE1. The dollar has been in decline with the bond purchases from the easing until this month. Strong monetary stimulus lead to a dollar sell-off.

Now we have a more complex risk-on environment. Stocks have moved sideways. The dollar has recovered losses, albeit partially due to Greek problems, and bonds have rallied. With greater certainty that QE3 will not come, the dollar strengthening, lower rates from declining inflation fears, and a more complex equity market seems like the right story. This no monetary stimulus story seems to have taken hold of the market, but the simple risk-on tale is not so easy to deal with given the current economic environment.

Economic growth for the first quarter was only 1.8 percent and the latest economic news does not show that we will have a fast acceleration in the economy. Housing is still a problem and the potential for a fiscal crisis with the debt ceiling vote is real. There may be a need for monetary stimulus given the lack of fiscal help and the fact that core inflation is still very modest. We know there is no QE3 now but the possibility may exist if we see slower economic growth. Without clarity on policy, there will be a monetary ease overhang. Bad numbers, possible help from Bernanke. Good numbers, no help. The dual role of the Fed generates more policy uncertainty.

The ECB crisis and Greek debt

The key to problem-solving is determining who has the problem. The EC and many finance ministers in the EU would like to see a reprofiling of Greek debt. A reprofiling would extend maturities of the existing debt which could also be called a soft restructuring or default. The problem arises with whether the ECB will take reprofiled bonds as collateral. This will have major ramifications for any restructuring. In short, reprofiling will not work if the ECB will not take the bonds as collateral. The ECB is saying that the banks and fiscal authorities will have to find the solution that works.

With inflation above target, there are strong reasons for why the ECB does not want to be in the bail-out business. The ECB has also not bought any bonds for the ninth week running. This was part of their "QE program" to help out during the Eu debt crises; however, it seems to sending clear signals that it is not going to be accomodative of monetizing bad debt.