Managed
futures shows good long-term performance versus equities. Yes? No? If you start
investing in the SocGen CTA index in 2000 and compare with any end year until
2015, you will shows positive returns as a stand-alone investment. However, if
you compare with the SP500, you may draw very different conclusions. When you
start and when you end the investment is critical for performance. Investors
know this, but sometimes showing the impact is stark and has a jarring effect
on asset allocation thinking.
Let's
look at two different charts. The first chart shows performance from 2000
through 2015 for the CTA index and for the SP500 (SPY) index. The second chart
compares performance from 2003 to the end of 2015. Which graph suggests whether
managed futures are a good investment? Start in 2000 and managed futures are a
champion performer. Start in 2003 and you may have to ask why this should be in
the portfolio. Start investing in 2000 and you include the fall in tech
stocks. Start investing in 2003 and you are including the stock recovery. These
extremes make the point that timing matters and shows the value of managed
futures if invested at the right time. Invest when times are turning bad and
you have a great investment. Invest when the equity cycle is turning up and
you will be disappointed on a relative basis. This is, of course, not looking
at diversification but just return performance. The investment may underperform
but there can be strong diversification gains.
Of
course, most investors know that the start and end date problem exists, but
there usually is not a lot of focus on the when and how long question through
studying various investment horizons. Certainly many marketers, if given the
chance, will select periods of good performance. This is one key reason why all
track records since inception should be presented. However, there may be a more
important lesson. Knowing when to add or subtract allocations is critical even
for long-term allocation decisions.
We have
provided three simple tables that reduce all of the start and end date
performance information into an easy to read format. Use the vertical date as
the start period and the horizontal as the end period. An investor can see what
the performance for any time length or any start period and end period. The
diagonals can show what a one year or n-year investment will look like with
different start dates.
The performance numbers in context are very interesting. These numbers
are more extreme since we are looking at cumulative returns and not annualized
returns. Managed futures will generally make money for any horizon except for
few years during the post-Financial Crisis period. The returns are for an
index. Individual managers may do better or worse.
Managed futures will not do as well on a relative basis when equities
are coming out of a trough. You can see that with the 2009-2013 start-date
vintages or 2003-2004 start-dates. If you look through long-term cycles,
buy and hold for equities is positive, but if you have cash flow needs over
shorter horizons managed futures can be helpful.
No comments:
Post a Comment