Monday, November 16, 2026

Narratives and inflation - same data, different stories

 


The provocative paper, "Beyond the numbers: Professional forecasters' narratives about inflation and stock market performance," conducts an analysis of the different narratives attached to professional forecasters after an inflation number is released. This has always been frustrating yet rarely discussed in academic research. You will have two forecasters, and they will have very different interpretations of inflation numbers. If economics is a science, shouldn't we see the same story when a news release occurs? If professional economists interpret the data, we should see them tell the same story, yet reality is quite different. 

The forecasters update expectations based on the narrative they spin. Getting the same information will not lead to the same choices or to a convergence of beliefs. 


Forecaster 1: “Decreasing inflation will lead to looser monetary policy and rising stock prices due to lower discount rates.”

Forecaster 2: “Higher inflation leads to higher interest rates, which decreases discounted cash flows and, thereby, reduces stock prices.”

Forecaster 3: “Firms will not be able to pass on increasing costs to their customers. Profit margins and, hence, firm profits will decrease, which reduces stock prices.”

Forecaster 4: “Profit margins will increase because firms are able to increase product prices while input prices are likely to decrease.”

The researchers provided the following six narratives:
(A) An easing in the development of inflation, a less restrictive monetary stance by the ECB, and
diminishing recession risks have a positive impact on the return-risk profile in 2023.
(B) DAX companies will continue to succeed in passing on rising costs to their customers. The
profit margins of DAX companies will, therefore, remain unchanged or even increase, which
has a positive impact on the return-risk profile of the DAX in 2023.
(C) The development of inflation does not impact the return-risk profile of the DAX.
(D) Positive and negative effects of inflation cancel each other out. Overall, the development of
inflation is neutral for the return-risk profile of the DAX in 2023.
(E) DAX companies will not succeed in passing on rising costs to their customers. The profit
margins of DAX companies will, therefore, decrease, which has a negative impact on the return-
risk profile of the DAX in 2023.
(F) Persistently high inflation rates, further interest rate hikes by the ECB, and increasing recession
risks will have a negative impact on the return-risk profile of the DAX in 2023.



There is no consistency in thinking, which is the reason why we have heterogeneous expectations about future returns. The same data will give different stories. 

No comments:

Post a Comment