Hedge funds and bank swap desks use many ways to classify alternative risk premia. The simplest categories are style and asset class. Styles can include value, carry, or momentum, and asset classes include equity, rates, commodities, carry, and credit. Another classification method is by where the risk-premium idea originated. There are two major sources: academic research and trader idea generation (implied risk premia). These could be classified as public and private alternative risk premia.
The academic path is simple. Research on factors or risk premia from academic working papers is weaponized into an investment or trading strategy that can be implemented through a variety of markets. A hedge fund or swap group will read the research, break it into replicable components, and convert it into a repeatable set of rules. The investment idea is not proprietary, but the conversion process requires quant and trading skill. The implementation or practical knowledge may be considered proprietary.
Unfortunately, some of the latest research states that after working papers are published or the research enters the public domain,n there is a significant and economically meaningful decline in the expected returns. Once the idea is out in the market, excess returns are arbitraged away. Crowds reduce the excess returns found in the research.
Unfortunately, some of the latest research states that after working papers are published or the research enters the public domain,n there is a significant and economically meaningful decline in the expected returns. Once the idea is out in the market, excess returns are arbitraged away. Crowds reduce the excess returns found in the research.
The second path for alternative risk premia comes through research done by hedge funds or banks and is not in the public domain. This is often in the form of firm-specific hedge fund strategies. This is a tradable and repeatable idea that a manager can believe is unique and requires special execution skill. The idea may have an economic foundation, but it may not have been explicitly tested in academic research. These ideas have often focused on volatility trading and replication of fund strategies like trend-following. If developed and marketed through a swaps desk, the investor is more directly dependent on the bank’s backtesting.
Academic work is more public and subject to crowding as investors follow the strategy once the idea is disseminated. Trader idea generation is private to the firm originating the idea but subject to the unique risks associated with specialized construction. There is a trade-off between receiving a generalized risk premium and one unique to the firm that generates and constructs the risk premium. The private (non-academic) risk premia requires more investor analysis and more trust in the bank swap desk construction and execution team. Our view is that the academic risk premia should be preferred, albeit the crowding issues must be addressed. A trader risk premium requires added return to compensate for their structural uniqueness
Academic work is more public and subject to crowding as investors follow the strategy once the idea is disseminated. Trader idea generation is private to the firm originating the idea but subject to the unique risks associated with specialized construction. There is a trade-off between receiving a generalized risk premium and one unique to the firm that generates and constructs the risk premium. The private (non-academic) risk premia requires more investor analysis and more trust in the bank swap desk construction and execution team. Our view is that the academic risk premia should be preferred, albeit the crowding issues must be addressed. A trader risk premium requires added return to compensate for their structural uniqueness


No comments:
Post a Comment