Friday, May 10, 2019

Endowments need help - Performance not strong versus balanced fund


Endowments are supposed to be the smart money, yet a recent exhaustive paper on return performance suggests otherwise. Large endowments do better than small endowments, but when you compare them with a simple 60/40 stock-bond balanced fund, they generate little alpha. See “Investment Returns and Distribution Policies of Non-Profit Endowment Funds” from ECGI.

I was shocked by the results given that endowments can be patient money with broad mandates. They have often been at the forefront of hedge funds, alternative investing, and private equity. Now, this could be a result of the way the authors partitioned the data. A $100 mm large fund cut-off is fairly low. 

An analysis of the endowments using a four-factor model shows that all alphas are negative, but the smaller endowments are slightly less negative. The fraction of endowments with negative alpha is just under 60 percent. The odds of creating positive alpha are less than a coin flip.

However, a deeper dive into alpha using a four-factor model suggests the top 20 universities are, at best, generating no alpha. This is better than the other partitions, but this does not mean that the large endowments should be patting themselves on the back.



The take-away from this study should not be surprising. Markets are competitive, and it is hard to produce added return versus a benchmark or a simple factor analysis. Some firms may be successful, but it is not easy to consistently add value.  Endowments do not seem to have any special investment skill.

Endowments’ current investment management approaches are not effective at generating excess returns. The processes in place for strategic and tactical asset allocation are not working. Endowments need to improve their investment behavior and do have a choice. They can move to a low-cost passive investing strategy or change the current active return-generating model. 

By passive investing, we mean a structured approach to holding strategic asset-class allocations or risk factors. A low-cost passive approach uses low-cost benchmark replicators and builds a well-diversified portfolio that is rebalanced through a set of rules. Be diversified at low cost. 

Changing the current return model may include moving away from the classic approach of adjusting asset-class allocations and seeking successful active managers, and moving to a factor-risk approach that allocates to a diversified pool of risk premia. The risk-premium diversification will be adjusted based on business-cycle risks. The focus is shifting from security and asset-class selection to factor management.

The choice of approach will depend on whether an investment committee believes it has an information edge in the market. A candid review will likely conclude that a low-cost passive approach may be a safe and effective investment strategy. Yet, a factor-based approach can be coupled with low fees to create a viable alternative.

No comments:

Post a Comment